Opposition want Tusk held “criminally responsible” for failings in lead up to Polish floods

The opposition Law and Justice (PiS) party has called for Prime Minister Donald Tusk to be held “criminally responsible” for failings relating to recent floods that have devasted the southwest of the country. They claim he “misinformed” citizens by downplaying the scale of the threat.

Tusk has rejected such accusations, accusing PiS of manipulating a statement he made just before the floods. He has also condemned one of the leaders of Confederation (Konfederacja), another opposition party, for suggesting that the authorities are hiding the true number of deaths caused by the disaster.

„Powody do paniki ma pan, dlatego że prawno-karna odpowiedzialność ciąży na panu”. Czarnek do Tuska#300POLITYKALIVE https://t.co/Y5njER3shG

— 300Polityka (@300polityka) September 26, 2024

PiS’s criticism has focused on remarks Tusk made on Friday 13 September, when he said that “the forecasts are not overly alarming” and that “there is no reason to panic”. Over the subsequent weekend, devastating floods began that are known to have taken at least seven lives.

The opposition argues that Tusk made his remarks despite having ample evidence from various sources, including warnings from the European Union, that an extreme weather event was imminent.

“Donald Tusk said at a press conference: ‘Ladies and gentlemen, the forecasts are not alarming, do not panic’,” said PiS spokesman Rafał Bochenek at a press conference on Thursday this week. “Reassuring, misinforming and de facto deceiving citizens about the scale of the threat.”

Sorry to interrupt your reading. The article continues below.

Notes from Poland is run by a small editorial team and published by an independent, non-profit foundation that is funded through donations from our readers. We cannot do what we do without your support.

Speaking alongside Bochenek, PiS MP Przemysław Czarnek told Tusk that “you have reason to panic because the legal and criminal responsibility rests on you”.

The previous day, during a special parliamentary session called to discuss the floods, Czarnek had likewise told Tusk that he “will be held legally and criminally responsible” for “negligence unprecedented in decades”.

“You caused catastrophic losses because you lied that there was no need to evacuate, because there was no reason to panic,” said Czarnek, quoted by news website Onet.

On Thursday, PiS published a video in which they recalled Tusk’s reassuring statements and accused him of failing to warn residents of Stronie Śląskie, Kłodzko and Nysa – some of the towns the hardest hit by the floods – of the impending disaster.

‼️ Donald Tusk zawiódł! #powódź #powódź2024 pic.twitter.com/jBP4IqUDix

— Prawo i Sprawiedliwość (@pisorgpl) September 26, 2024

Tusk, however, has rejected the opposition’s allegations, calling on them to “stop manipulating”. He said that his remarks regarding forecasts on the morning of Friday 13 September were accurate at the time.

But he also noted that he had made clear to people that, “whatever the forecast is, we do not underestimate the danger”.

“From day one, we told all residents – and repeated it every day many times – ‘do not underestimate the recommendations of the fire department and police about the need to evacuate’,” added Tusk.

Southern Poland has been hit by major flooding, which has so far claimed one life.

The prime minister, on a visit to the worst-affected area, appealed to residents to obey evacuation orders https://t.co/bsdRiVfo59

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) September 15, 2024

Meanwhile, one of the leaders of the far-right Confederation party, another opposition group, also criticised the government’s handling of the crisis.

“In our country, preparations for evacuation were not made until the last moment,” Krzysztof Bosak told broadcaster RMF FM on Thursday. “In the Czech Republic, Italy and Austria, the [crisis] management looked completely different.”

He criticised Tusk for failing to “name those to blame for the lack of preparation…for the fact that local communities and local government officials were taken completely by surprise by the impending flood wave”.

Na słowa @krzysztofbosak o rzekomo zakłamanych danych w sprawie liczby ofiar zareagowała policja.https://t.co/9MLVICRgm7

— Interia (@Int_Wydarzenia) September 26, 2024

Bosak also claimed that the government was underreporting the number of victims. He noted that Austria and Poland have the same number of officially reported victims, seven.

“I do not believe that the same number of people died in Poland, because the extent of the flooding was much greater,” said Bosak, who cited claims that flood victims who died in cars had been classified as road deaths.

Those claims were rejected and condemned by the national commander of the police, Marek Boroń, who told broadcaster Polsat that Bosak was “misleading people, disinformation society”. Tusk called Bosak’s remarks “exceptionally disgusting”.

This week, the government appealed to Poles, including politicians, not to fall for and to spread disinformation regarding the floods. They claimed that evidence indicates Russian-linked accounts have been propagating false claims online.

Poland’s government says that Russian-linked accounts have been seeking to „cause panic” by spreading false information regarding ongoing floods.

During the first four days of the crisis, it recorded a 300% increase in disinformation being shared online https://t.co/GzZ6WzUwf5

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) September 26, 2024

Main image credit: KPRM/Flickr (under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)