Tusk pledges further “fortification” of Belarus border amid “hybrid war of illegal migration”

Prime Minister Donald Tusk has pledged to increase Poland’s defences on its border with Belarus, where he says it is facing a “hybrid war”, including through “illegal migration”.

However, his approach has been met with criticism from humanitarian organisations as well as an MEP from the prime minister’s own political group and renowned film director Agnieszka Holland, who accused the government of continuing the “inhuman rhetoric” of its predecessors.

Premier @DonaldTusk podczas wypowiedzi dla mediów po odprawie z żołnierzami Wojska Polskiego oraz funkcjonariuszami Straży Granicznej i Policji: Chcę wyrazić najwyższe uznanie dla dowódców wojska, straży granicznej i policji – państwo Polskie jest z nimi w każdej chwili. Ta… pic.twitter.com/vfwtzKK4sh

— Kancelaria Premiera (@PremierRP) May 11, 2024

On Saturday, Tusk visited the border and met with soldiers, border guards and police who have been working to secure the frontier amid an ongoing crisis that has seen tens of thousands of migrants and asylum seekers – mostly from the Middle East, Asia and Africa – try to cross from Belarus since 2021.

“I came today primarily so that both the commanders and their subordinates have no doubt that the Polish state and the Polish government are with them in every situation here on the border,” said the prime minister.

During his speech, he promised that “there will be no [spending] limits when it comes to securing the border”. He also announced that the government has begun “intensive work on [building] modern…fortifications along the entire Polish border with the east”.

The “brutal truth” is that the “survival of Western civilisation” depends on preventing “uncontrolled migration”, says Polish Prime Minister @donaldtusk.

„We [must] wake up and understand that we have to protect our borders…[or] our world will collapse” https://t.co/mPwGIMCoU9

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) February 12, 2024

“This border is an absolutely unique place due to the pressure of illegal migration,” said Tusk. “In fact we are dealing with a developing hybrid war.”

The latter term is one that was regularly used by Poland’s former Law and Justice (PiS) government as well as the European Union to describe the way in which Belarus was encouraging and helping migrants to cross illegally into the EU.

Under Tusk’s government, which replaced PiS in power in December, border forces have continued a controversial practice of “pushing back” into Belarus many of those who cross illegally. This has been found illegal by some Polish courts and condemned by rights groups and a UN special rapporteur.

While visiting the border on Saturday, Tusk announced legal changes “that will give our soldiers and officers a full sense of legal security in the activities you undertake here”. He did not, however, provide any further details.

Poland carried out over 6,000 so-called „pushbacks” of migrants who crossed the border from Belarus between July 2023 and January 2024.

It is the first time the government has released data on the practice, which has been criticised by human rights groups https://t.co/DA5mCB7vAC

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) February 7, 2024

The Tusk government’s policies and rhetoric regarding the Belarus border have been met with criticism even by some within his own camp.

“I dreamt that Poland would be the first country to say: ‘We do not use pushbacks and we do not violate human rights.’ So I am disappointed,” Janina Ochojska, an MEP from Tusk’s European People’s Party and president of Polish Humanitarian Action (PAH), told news website Wirtualna Polska.

“The methods have remained the same…[and] unfortunately inhuman rhetoric is still used,” added renowned film director Agnieszka Holland, whose critically acclaimed film Green Border last year depicted the plight of refugees at the Polish-Belarusian border.

She accused the new border guard spokesman of using “dehumanising” language by describing those crossing the border as the “tools” of Belarusian leader Alexander Lukashenko. Holland added that “muscle flexing” by Poland regarding the border is exactly what “Lukashenko and Putin want”.

Director Agnieszka Holland is suing Poland’s justice minister for likening her new film – which depicts mistreatment of migrants at the Polish border – to Nazi propaganda.

The film has been praised by critics and tipped for the top prize at @la_Biennale https://t.co/WGWO8OZLW4

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) September 7, 2023

Such criticism was, however, rejected by deputy defence minister Paweł Zalewski, who told Wirtualna Polska that strengthening the border was in fact being done “for humanitarian reasons: the more difficult it is to cross, the fewer people will want to do it”.

Another deputy defence minister, Cezary Tomczyk, told broadcaster TVN on Sunday that the government is working to improve the border defences built by the PiS government, which he called “a makeshift solution” that migrants have continued to be able to bypass.

A leaked internal border guard document published earlier this year showed that 2023 saw a rise in the number of attempted crossings into Poland from Belarus. It also showed a rise in the number then reaching Germany, which is the most common target for the migrants

This year, Polish border guards have continued to note large numbers of attempted crossings, including a “very aggressive” group of around 140 people last Friday. They threw stones and tree branches at Polish officers, who managed to prevent them from crossing.

Poland has charged 36 members of a gang allegedly responsible for smuggling thousands of migrants across the Belarus border and for financing terrorism.

Investigators have identified cryptocurrency accounts linked to Hezbollah and Palestinian Jihad https://t.co/LvonxJL56a

— Notes from Poland 🇵🇱 (@notesfrompoland) May 8, 2024

Notes from Poland is run by a small editorial team and published by an independent, non-profit foundation that is funded through donations from our readers. We cannot do what we do without your support.

Main image credit: Krystian Maj/KPRM (under CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Agata Pyka is an assistant editor at Notes from Poland. She is a journalist and a political communication student at the University of Amsterdam. She specialises in Polish and European politics as well as investigative journalism and has previously written for Euractiv and The European Correspondent.